GEt Quote
  • Mechanical Testing of Plastics: Match the Test to the Question

    Nov 15, 2026 | ACS MATERIAL LLC

    Mechanical testing of plastics starts from the question you need answered: how strong and stiff is the material, how tough is it when struck, or how hard is its surface. Tensile, impact and hardness tests answer those three questions, and none of them stands in for another. This guide is the index to the mechanical and hardness testing guides in the library: it matches each question to a test, says what each test does not tell you, and quotes what the Polytevo Series pages for the universal testing machine, the Charpy and Izod impact testers and the Shore durometer say, using only what those pages say.

    What this guide covers. Choosing between tensile, impact and hardness testing for plastics, as general method background, and routing to the detailed guides. It does not give property values, it does not rank materials, and it does not say which result a specification requires.
    Three lab instruments in a row: a tensile frame holding a flat bar, a pendulum impact tester and a durometer on a stand
    Three questions, three instruments: a tensile frame (how strong), a pendulum impact tester (how tough) and a durometer on its stand (how hard).

    1.  Mechanical testing of plastics: one question, one test

    Match the test to the question and write the method reference with the result. A tensile test pulls a specimen and records force against elongation, from which the tensile strength, the tensile modulus and other aspects of the stress-strain relationship are determined.1 A pendulum impact test strikes a specimen in a single swing, determines absorbed energy and records the failure outcome required by the selected method.2,3,4 A durometer presses an indenter into the surface and reads the indentation hardness.5

    The questionThe testWhat you getWhere to read more
    How strong and stiff is it?Tensile testA stress-strain curve: modulus, yield, strength, strain at breakTensile Testing of Plastics: Reading the Stress-Strain Curve; the machine in How to Choose a Universal Testing Machine for Plastics
    How does it behave when struck?Pendulum impact test, Charpy or IzodAbsorbed energy and failure outcome; a result per unit of cross-section or widthCharpy vs Izod Impact Testing for Plastics; the arithmetic in Choosing a Pendulum Energy and Calculating Impact Strength
    How hard is its surface?Shore durometer, scale A or DAn indentation hardness number with its scale letterShore A vs Shore D Hardness

    Test method reference: ISO 527-1:2019 and ASTM D638-22 for tensile properties, ISO 179-1:2026, ISO 180:2023 and ASTM D256-26 for impact, and ISO 868:2003 and ASTM D2240-15(2021) for durometer hardness.1,6,7,8,4,5,9

    2.  What each test does not tell you

    Each answer has a boundary, and the methods say so themselves.

    • Tensile. The result belongs to the specimen, the speed and the conditioning. The withdrawn 1993 ISO text says that results from specimens of different dimensions, or prepared under different conditions, may not be comparable, and that factors such as the speed of testing and conditioning can also influence the results.10
    • Impact. The result is a property of the whole test: the bar, the notch, the pendulum and the way the bar is held. The withdrawn 1993 ISO impact texts say the method should not be used as a source of data for design calculations of components.2
    • Hardness. The durometer method is an empirical method intended primarily for control purposes, and no simple relationship exists between its result and any fundamental property of the material.5 No simple relationship exists either between measurements made with one type of durometer and those made with another.9

    Do not treat results from different methods or scales as interchangeable, apply an unvalidated conversion, or report a number without its method, specimen and test conditions.

    3.  How to choose: four prompts

    1. What is the question? Stiffness or strength points to tensile; behavior under a sudden blow points to impact; surface indentation points to hardness. If a specification asks for two of them, run both, and do not expect one to predict the other.
    2. What does the specification or customer name? If a method is named, use it, with the notch, scale or specimen it prescribes. Keep the instrument, specimen and conditioning consistent across lots where the method allows.
    3. What form is the sample? Molded or cut bars suit tensile and impact tests; a flat plaque or pressed piece suits a durometer if it is thick enough and flat. Specimen preparation can affect measured properties. For example, Parodi and co-workers investigated effects of preparation and conditioning on the deformation and failure behavior of injection-molded polyamide 6.11
    4. What will you record? The method reference and edition, the specimen, the conditioning, the speed or pendulum, the number tested and the units. Handbooks of polymer testing treat these points property by property.12,13,14

    Test at room temperature is the default in these guides. For heating and cooling modules see the existing guide on temperature modules for universal testing machines, and for stage-based tensile work see in-situ tensile testing at variable temperature.

    4.  What the Polytevo Series pages say

    The Polytevo Series Universal Testing Machine page lists tensile, compression, bending, shear, tear, peel and penetration testing of metallic and non-metallic materials, including plastics, in its “where it fits” line; the guides in this library deal with its tensile use.

    The Polytevo Series Charpy Impact Tester page describes a digital Charpy impact tester for impact testing of rigid plastics and other non-metallic materials.

    The Polytevo Series Izod Impact Tester page describes an Izod impact tester for measuring the impact toughness of plastics and other non-metallic materials.

    The Polytevo Series Shore Durometer page describes pointer-type Shore durometers, Shore A and Shore D, with a constant-load test stand, for testing the hardness of vulcanized rubber and plastic products.

    Question, page snapshot 15 November 2026Polytevo Series page
    How strong and stiff?Polytevo Series Universal Testing Machine
    How tough when struck?Polytevo Series Charpy Impact Tester and Polytevo Series Izod Impact Tester
    How hard?Polytevo Series Shore Durometer

    The pages identify applications and configurations. Suitability for a particular material, specimen and method still needs to be established. Supplied configurations are confirmed on the quotation, and the detailed guides listed in section 1 give each instrument its own page values.

    5.  A minimal test plan for a new formulation

    When a new material or formulation arrives, a short plan keeps the three tests consistent.

    1. Write the question and the method reference first, so that the specimen, notch or scale is chosen to suit the method and not the other way round.
    2. Within each comparison series, use the applicable preparation and conditioning procedures consistently, except for variables deliberately included in the experiment. Different tests may require different specimen forms and preparation procedures.
    3. Test a set, not a single specimen. Test the number of specimens required by the applicable material specification and selected method edition; record exclusions and replacement specimens.
    4. Record how each specimen failed, not only its number: a break type for impact, where the break occurred for tensile, and the time of reading for hardness.10,2,5
    5. Keep the instrument and the settings consistent across the series where the method allows, and write down any change.

    Historical note. The withdrawn 1993 ISO texts asked for a minimum of five tensile specimens and, for impact, a minimum of ten, or five when the coefficient of variation was below 5%, unless the material standard said otherwise; this describes those withdrawn editions and is not a default prescription for a test plan.10,2

    6.  Why the tests are not interchangeable

    Three tempting shortcuts are worth naming. A Charpy value is not an Izod value: the two tests load the bar differently and may report different quantities, and the units can differ; see Charpy vs Izod Impact Testing for Plastics. A Shore A reading is not a Shore D reading: there is no universal Shore A-to-D conversion for arbitrary materials, so measure the specified scale rather than substituting a converted value; see Shore A vs Shore D Hardness. A hardness number is not a strength: hardness is an empirical indentation measurement used mainly for control, while strength comes from a tensile test.9,5

    What can be done safely is to compare like with like: the same method, specimen type, speed or pendulum where valid, conditioning and units. The route from material to test, including the specimen-preparation steps that come first, is set out in the Lab-Scale Polymer Processing and Testing: A Workflow Guide.

    7.  Keep Exploring the Lab-Scale Polymer Processing Knowledge Hub

    This guide belongs to the ACS Material library on lab-scale polymer processing and testing, built around the Polytevo Series by ACS Material. Start from the Lab-Scale Polymer Processing and Testing: A Workflow Guide, which places every stage of the work, from material to test, on one route. The other guides on mechanical and hardness testing are:

    8.  Before you request a quote

    To help identify a suitable configuration, describe the testing you need to run. Please tell us:

    • the question you need answered: strength and stiffness, behavior under impact, hardness, or a combination;
    • the materials and the form of the samples, bars, sheet or plaques;
    • the test method references you work to;
    • the number of specimens you test per sample and how you report results;
    • whether you also test at other temperatures.

    Send these through Request a Quote. Specifications are as published on each product page, and final configurations are confirmed on quotation.

    9.  FAQ

    Which test should I run first on a new plastic?

    The one that answers your question. Tensile gives strength and stiffness, impact gives behavior under a sudden blow, and hardness gives surface indentation; none of them replaces another.1,2,5

    Can a hardness test replace a tensile test?

    No. The durometer method is an empirical method intended primarily for control purposes, and no simple relationship exists between its result and any fundamental property of the material.5

    Can I compare a Charpy result with an Izod result?

    Not by a simple rule. The tests load the bar differently and may report different quantities, so compare Charpy with Charpy and Izod with Izod unless a validated relationship exists; see the guide on Charpy and Izod in this library.2,3

    Do I need to record the method reference?

    Yes. The withdrawn 1993 ISO texts say that results from specimens of different dimensions, notches or conditions may not be comparable, so the method reference and the conditions go with every number.10,2

    Where do I read about tests at other temperatures?

    In the existing guides on temperature modules for universal testing machines and in-situ tensile testing at variable temperature.

    10.  References

    1Test method reference: ISO 527-1:2019. Plastics — Determination of tensile properties — Part 1: General principles. Source record
    2Test method reference: ISO 179:1993. Plastics — Determination of Charpy impact strength. Second edition, 1993; a withdrawn edition. Public preview copy read for this guide: Source record
    3Test method reference: ISO 180:1993. Plastics — Determination of Izod impact strength. Second edition, 1993; a withdrawn edition. Public preview copy read for this guide: Source record
    4Test method reference: ASTM D256-26. Standard Test Methods for Determining the Izod Pendulum Impact Resistance of Plastics. Source record
    5Test method reference: ISO 868:2003. Plastics and ebonite — Determination of indentation hardness by means of a durometer (Shore hardness). Source record
    6Test method reference: ASTM D638-22. Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of Plastics. Source record
    7Test method reference: ISO 179-1:2026. Plastics — Determination of Charpy impact properties — Part 1: Non-instrumented impact test. Source record
    8Test method reference: ISO 180:2023. Plastics — Determination of Izod impact strength. Source record
    9Test method reference: ASTM D2240-15(2021). Standard Test Method for Rubber Property—Durometer Hardness. Source record
    10Test method reference: ISO 527-1:1993. Plastics — Determination of tensile properties — Part 1: General principles. First edition, 1993; a withdrawn edition. Public preview copy read for this guide: Source record
    11Parodi E, Peters GWM, Govaert LE. Structure-properties relations for polyamide 6, part 2: influence of processing conditions during injection moulding on deformation and failure kinetics. Polymers. 2018;10(7):779. DOI: 10.3390/polym10070779
    12Shah V. Handbook of Plastics Testing and Failure Analysis. 3rd ed. Wiley; 2006. DOI: 10.1002/0470100427
    13Brown R, ed. Handbook of Polymer Testing. CRC Press; 1999. DOI: 10.1201/9781482270020
    14Grellmann W, Seidler S, eds. Polymer Testing. 2nd ed. Hanser; 2013. DOI: 10.3139/9781569905494
    Disclaimer: This guide provides general educational information based on the cited sources and dated product-page snapshots. ACS Material makes no representations or warranties, either express or implied, regarding the suitability of any Polytevo Series product for any particular purpose or the accuracy of the information listed here. Product statements are those published on the Polytevo Series product pages on 15 November 2026; specifications are as published on each page and final configurations are confirmed on quotation. This guide contains no measured results. Literature statements are those of the cited authors and were not produced with Polytevo Series equipment unless the source says so. Standards are named only as test method references; this guide makes no claim about the standards status of any product. Always follow the method reference, the product documentation and your laboratory’s safety procedures.